I bought 3 bar stools. Two of them were just what I wanted. The third which shipped separately was fine physically, but had a terrible musty odor. I tried to "air it out" for days, but the smell continued and I had to put it in the basement. The stools are comfortable and easy to put together. I would give 5 stars to the two good stools and 1 star to the musty one as it is unusable.