I think the quality of the Shelby collection is great!  We purchased the sofa, ottoman and arm chair. The assembly was easy.  All we had to do was screw on the legs and place he cushions.  The cushions are definitely firm and I think they will hold up well.  If I could offer one suggestion ~  it would be nice if Wayfair offered to Scotch guard the furniture.  I think it would be a pretty nice selling point and be beneficial for furniture items that have woven material.