Beautiful design, good weight.  I believe these are 2nd quality as 5 of the pieces I received had sharp torn edges on the soup spoon bowls or heavy indents running the length of both sides of the handle edges.  One spoon cut my husbands mouth before we realized there were some issues with the edges.  Luckily I'm a jeweler so I filed, sanded and re-polished the problem areas on all 5 pieces.  I could of returned the 5 items however I had the skills to fix flaws.  Look carefully at all the pieces once they arrive so you can return problem pieces if necessary.  Quality on rest of set was good.