I am very pleased with the finish of this unit, and the look of the firebox is nice when turned on. I gave it a 4 because it was sent to me with two right side panels instead of a left and a right, so I haven't been able to build it as of yet! Customer service has the part on the way, so it will not be long. This was one of the largest pre-made mantel units I could find online so I am happy with the substantial size as well.