These chairs were easy to assemble and are very comfortable.  I would give them a 5 except that they are rusting somewhere underneath the brown wrap that covers the legs.  They are patio bar stools, do I expected that I could leave them outside.  They are leaving rust stains on my deck though, so I have been bringing them inside every night.  I do not want to return them because they suit our purposes perfectly but I also do not want them to leave rust stains on the deck and I do not want to have to bring them out of the elements daily.