This is a replacement for a Kitchenaid and so far I found that every bad review I saw on this unit seem to be wrong. The two issue I saw when reading the reviews was the light and ice maker.   The ice maker is keeping up with my family very well.   The light in the unit is ok and I seem to be able to see everything I need too.  The only fault I could find with it is how you switch back and forth with ice and water.  When you go to cube then want to go back to water you have to go through the crush then water. However I can live with this.  Seem to be a good buy for the price.   Check back in a year and we will see how it is working