It'll have to do, but this cushion was too small for my papasan chair by at least a couple of inches in diameter.  Also, the cushion needs more, well, cushioning.  I can feel the wood of the chair through it, and lacks the overall comfort level of my original from Pier1.  Less importantly, but noteworthy, their version of indigo seems to be more of an evergreenish blue color, different from the deep blue/violet color I expected.