I purchased this dish drain to replace one that I had used for a least 20 years.  I wanted something large and sturdy.  This is both of these things. I have made it work for my needs even though the tray is smaller than the rack itself.   The rack slides inside the rack instead of the rack sitting upon a wider surface. I place an additional rubber mat under the rack for any water that does not get collected in the tray it comes with. I like the silverware caddy.  It is quite large and has removable lids with guides to hold individual flatware and a slot for knives etc.  It also has a larger space in the middle that can hold larger utensils. I gave a rating of 4 stars because it does not hold dishes very securely.  They do tend to fall over easily compared to the previous one I used.