One was perfect, but sadly for us, on the other one the holes were drilled in the wrong place. We could assemble it but it doesn't look right and can never be tight. By the time we got the second one assembled and realized it was faulty, we had spent some considerable time trying to figure it out. We were not about to disassemble, pack it and ship it back. We are living with the faulty one but wish it had been just like the first one and then you would have had a very satisfied customer.