This shelf arrived in excellent condition, was easy to assemble and is sturdy.  As importantly, it is a very good value for the money.  It is very nice-looking, does not look cheap or flimsy.  I am very happy with it--it fit into the space I needed to fill perfectly.

Pros: Solid, attractive, reasonably priced.
Cons: metal hardware is visible, but I may try to cover it with black tape.