We had an older Samsung 3-door refrigerator, with the icemaker in the upper compartment and external water/ice dispenser.  We had the common ice-over issue with the icemaker, but generally liked the unit. Unfortunately, a couple of weeks a go the freezer section completely failed. We bought the new Bespoke 3-door and couldn't be happier.  Going from 24cu ft to 31cu ft has been great, and having the icemaker in the freezer compartment makes much more sense.  While would rather have not given up some of the freezer space, this is a fair compromise.