The quality of the pull is good but the screws were too long so we had to cut them all back to get them to fit.  Additionally, if you are changing out existing 3" drawer pulls, it's important to note that these do NOT align with the existing 3" holes. We bought 30 of them and measured them and found they were all 3/16ths of an inch to narrow of the 3" holes.  We are able to make the holes a bit bigger to accommodate the shorter width but it's been very time consuming to get them all changed out.....  I would have rated these as a 5 for it not been for all the issues.