I purchased two of these, I was definitely skeptical-especially with some of the reviews, however, I'm very pleased with these. They definitely aren't as nice/comfortable as the ones I replaced, but my previous ones were much more expensive.  If you read and go by the measurements, and not the description of "oversized", you will not be disappointed. Overall they are very attractive and what I was expecting. I did give only 4 stars due to they could use some more stuffing in the head/neck area and could use a little more length on the reclining leg area. Otherwise a great purchase and a great value.