First of, Wayfair customer service is amazing, and why I continue to buy with confidence from Wayfair/Allmodern.  My piece had some issues, nicks and scratches, uneven/spotty staining.  However, even if it has been perfect this was off.   From the photo, and of those posted by other reviewers-I had not expected it to be as orange.  Mine was heavily orange-y.  Made me wonder if they skipped a second coat or something, since I had the uneven stain.