I would give this desk a 4.5. It is really pretty and made of high quality materials. It was packed well and did not seem to be damaged during shipping. But there were a couple small dings/damages that are annoying. And the two drawers are not aligned exactly the same. They are off slightly which catches the eye. Overall it’s a great desk and I’m glad I bought it. Helpful note: the drawer pulls and screws are in the drawers.