I purchased two of these and one with arms....

PROS: 
Delivery was quick and to my front door. 
Packaging was very thorough and product had no damage. 
Assembly was quick (for me) about 15 minutes per stool (the majority of time taken was for unpacking, unwrapping each piece).
Looks classic and elegant. 

CONS:
Compared to the Jones bar stool with arms, the seat is NOT as big... it COULD be larger.  
I am average size at 5'7" @ 150 lbs... and the seat, it could be a LITTLE larger, yes, but not a deal breaker. 
I DID order a second Jones bar stool with arms for comfort.  This price is higher of course, but depends on want you want.... I want comfort (for the price).  

SUMMARY: 
I am pleased with the bar stools.  

Hope this helps!