I’ll start by saying the quality is great.  I love the navy, although my husband swears it’s black! It’s not - definitely navy blue! We get a lot of wind in our backyard and I thought I would try this type. Our old one finally broke after 10 years when it lifted with our table (and it was closed but not tied) so we needed to purchase a new one. I researched a lot and really liked how this one was made with a better material than the others. Our old one faded after 4 years so I’m hoping this one won’t fade as fast. I’m taking away a star only because I hate the placement of the switch for the lights. I’m really short (5’1”) and I can’t reach the switch without either kneeling on our table or with the umbrella closed a little and pulling it down on that end. Our old one had the switch near the crank which was really nice. Also I liked how my old one would tilt by the crank. This one (and I knew when I bought it) has a push button at the top to tilt it. Again, not ideal for short people.