My first impression was that the Underbed shoe storage was a little flimsy, (but it was pretty inexpensive.) The separate compartments are not connected to the bottom. I probably would have rated it a 5 if they were connected to the bottom.  I did put my shoes in it and it did end up working. 8>)
ps. Men's size shoes would most likely not fit in it.

I will order from Wayfair again.