First the instructions were pretty good but not super clear and I ended up making 1 mistake that cannot be fixed. In the picture to top side panel over the shelf I have that on upside down. so the nice finish is on the top not the bottom like it should be. You really cant tell unless your looking into the shelf while kneeling. 
The other reason for the -1 star is because the fit of the components while assembling isn't perfect. there are some gaps when done again hard to notice but they're there. Also this is particle board. I re-enforced all the connecting edges with gorilla wood glue to add some extra strength. 
All that said it does look pretty good when finished. I am satisfied with my $169 purchase. I would not pay more than $200 for this product. 
When built feels solid, looks attractive, and will add refinement to your starter dining room. Later it can be re-purposed elsewhere.