I'd give it 4.5 stars. the lamp itself is great. great design and industrial look. The loss of a half star is because of the included light bulbs.  While they are the Edison design, they are incandescent and have low wattage.  In this day and age, they should include Edison LED bulbs. 

And lastly, Wayfair, what's with all the styrofoam. There has got to be better packing material than that.