I give it 5 stars regardless of a scratch along the right top side of the nightstand. You can only see it if you look for it and it doesn't bother me. I can easily camouflage it with a wood re-touch marker. Otherwise it is a really nice piece of furniture, arrived very well packaged (earlier than expected) and I only had to attach the legs. It looks very well with the rest of the furniture in my bedroom. The price was great, too.