When our order first arrived, the round part of the table was split in half, I think two of the table legs had small cracks, the leaf had a small crack, and parts of the table top were unfinished and disappointing. All four chairs were a bit wobbly (until you sit in them), but were in great shape. 

I called Wayfair and the representative was SUPER nice. They sent a replacement table which was in much better shape, however, you can see some wood filler in the table. For $400, I do not expect perfection, so I would say I am 98 happy with it now. If I could rate it on overall looks (not quality) and comfort, I would give it a 5. I am really glad we purchased it. I am also thankful Wayfair replaced it so quickly. Every time I pass by the table, I think, I love our new table!