I'll give this a 4 because ultimately I'm deciding to keep the dresser. However, mine arrived with a couple of scratches here and there. Lucky for me, they were in areas that aren't visible once put together. Like everyone else said, the instructions are confusing and inaccurate. If you follow the instructions, you will wind up with the drawer on top. It's an easy fix of just switching the top and bottom but still an inconvenience for someone who is an avid instruction follower like me. All in all, it'll suit my needs.