This bookcase arrived in good shape. Two people were able to put it together easily, and the directions were mostly understandable. I'm giving it 4 stars instead of 5 because one of the rails was slightly short- not enough to affect function, but it does affect the appearance. Also, I few of the pre-drilled holes didn't line up exactly, so that I was still able to get the screw in with a little effort, but at an angle. Overall, it's not perfect, but I'm pleased enough.