Exceeded my expectations! Really nice for the price. I was skeptical about how much light these would block considering the lack of lining, but they’re very effective. Aesthetically they’re nice for the money as well. They don’t look cheap. The color is rich but also appears neutral, the balance of pattern and sheen are subtle which adds some sophistication to my space. However mine are already damaged by my teenager brat cat. Soooo they’re not at all kitty friendly.