I think this pillow is great if used for specific needs.  The shag on the pillow looks great, not cheap or sparse.  I have 2 rattan chairs which needed some type of pillow against the back spokes to make it more comfortable.  These pillows were perfect!  They have the flat back which is firm and doesn't collapse, and the very fluffy shag in the front which makes them very comfortable to sit against.  Plus they aren't so thick as to stick out too much onto the chair.  I have received many compliments on them, and I can't believe what I paid for them.  One of the best purchases I made this year.