I got two of these in red. They are really pretty and firm. I wanted them to be firm because I hate saggy furniture. Makes it look old and worn out. I took a star away because the front leg on one of the chairs is set back about a half an inch further the rest of the legs. You have to be looking really hard at it to notice though. But it definitely wasn't a big enough deal to send it back and deal with the hassle of an exchange. Eventually I will drill another hole to fix it but right now I'm okay with it.