Purchased to replace a full depth unit. So far it has been a very pleasant unit. The ice maker is great and supplies enough ice for our needs. The craft ice maker, however,  is SLOW. We have used the door in a door more often than we thought and find it very convenient. The value of this unit will be in how long we can rely on it for operation with no failures. I hope LG has done their work and make it suitable for purchase. So far, so good.