Wish I could give this one a 4.5 - came in a small (for the item), manageable box, easy-to-assemble, looks as expected. Really like the 4 struts on the inside to keep the sides from bowing out. That's a key feature. The struts simply line up with the holes you've already been using to assemble the box and screw in place there. Perfect. 

My reason for a 4.5 instead of a 5? The screws are silver and stand out against the bonze finish. And the item is packaged with styrofoam. I ding ANY company that uses this horrible product. We have other options. That said the packaging was excellent and the product arrived in perfect condition.