I love the look of this light.  It shipped/arrived quickly.  Directions were very simple to follow.  I am rating a 3 because one of the verticle metal rods is sodered crooked.  I is very tricky to get the 3 arched rods to tighten and align.  These 2 issues cause my fixture to hang crooked.  It is not worth taking down and returning.  I will live with it.