I'd actually give it a 2 1/2 star for quality. I ordered 4 stools. 2 came in damaged. I emailed Wayfair and they sent me a new one no hassles. That is why I rated it 3. At least I know they will fix their issues. Regarding te quality of the stools. They are not great however the stools wEre inexpensive. I was just expecting a little more. Ian concerned that the seats will cave in. They do not appear to have much supporrt. Also the color resembles for of a black than an espresso, not a brown undertone.