The first one I ordered came with minor damage, from the looks of it, while it was installed. As expected, Wayfair customer service was awesome, took care of it no problem and shipped me a new one. The second one came (much quicker than the first!). There was no damage but did have weird defects on the front and side. 

The piece is built of wood, drawers are quality and slide nicely, the top drawers are lined with felt. But the piece is finished in a plastic-y veneer, so these "defects" are assumed to look like distressed wood, but it just doesn't work. 

Update: The finish chipped off the front a few days after v2 came. Emailed the customer service rep that was handling my case at Wayfair, they gave me a credit, no questions asked. LOVE WAYFAIR CUSTOMER SERVICE!