I had purchased these lanterns from Costco several years ago. It was time to replace them  and I found them on Wayfair. The metal has been replaced by a very heavy duty plastic but other than that they are the same. Even though one came with a broken starter I have still given them 5 stars because I called Wayfair and the broken one was replaced Immediately and without my having to go through the hassle of returning the broken one. Wouldn't it be nice if we could get such wonderful customer service from other vendors! I love these lanterns as much as the ones I replaced.