Just what I thought. I needed an inexpensive liner to use transitionally before our bathroom Reno was complete. The comments about the magnets not sticking were not true for us, except if you bump into the liner it sticks to you and will pull away from tub, or if the shower liner is doubled over. Otherwise, the magnets work fine. Another comment said it was short, it is the perfect size for a tub, hitting about 2” from button of tub. Perfect for a tub, so doesn’t drag on floor to get mold, but maybe a problem with a shower, just need to measure it properly to make sure it works for you. We got the clear, because it was on sale.