I read the reviews about the stainless steel top scratching easily and it is true.  But I still love the look of stainless steel and we are careful when using it  I would have gone with black granite but there was already too much black in my kitchen.  I am happy with my choice.  Once the island is together, it is quite sturdy and solid.  My 2 teenage kids put it together in about 3 hours.  Love it!