We love our Penny recliners. Bought two light gray a year ago and they are holding up well. They are perfect for a small space and comfortable to sit in. We love that they rock and rotate. Some things we don’t like about the chair is that it is really difficult to close. You have to push really hard with your feet to get it to snap into place - it has gotten a little easier after a year, but not much. Additionally, they don’t stay reclined all the way back with out some effort. The slightest body movement forward and you are no longer reclining at its fullest.  I don’t think I would buy again- but, they fit our needs for now.