I went through FOUR of these and every single one had scratches on the back part (facing toward the front).  One even had the planter part falling off the back.  AllModern had to get involved and ask the shipper directly to make sure to inspect the product before shipping and I still received the last one with minor scratches on it.  They must be storing these on top of each other and the metal is scraping off the finish on the ones above and below it.  AllModern was great about trying to get a good one, it just didn't happen and I gave up.