I really like these curtains.  They are a little more modern than I usually like but I have a geometric theme going on with circles in my family room and these added to the decor nicely.  I picked the taupe color (I needed a neutral color)  which is actually more towards gold but they match my colors (tuscan colors) great! I gave them a 4 instead of 5 because the cut outs which were done by laser were not all clean cuts but I just used a pair of sharp scissors to finish the cuts that weren't quite completed.  Overall I am very happy with them.  They are on the dressy side but add a little elegance to a casual room.