Mine came with a split and splintered side wall of the top tray. The wood is not very strong and the handles do not seem secured well enough due to the cheap wood used. I used two special wood screws to put the tray side wall back together and then furniture polish to cover the splits which went the entire length of the tray side wall and I also covered the scratches in the very soft wood. Poor quality and poor quality control. I do not recommend buying this product. Shame, it is a perfect match with my table and chairs.