Bought one as a sample  - very comfortable, a little light markings on the seat I could not get off but not enough to return.  Very comfortable. I'm going to purchase 5 more, I'll use 4 at my dining table and put one in each bedroom at the built in desks for a new modern home I'm building. Would have given 5 stars if there had not been the slight markings on the seat.

Pros: Very comfortable and great rendition of the original chair - also surprising comfortable with the protrusion near where your lower back is.
Cons: slight discoloration lines on the seat but not enough for me to return my sample chair.