I bought 2 about 6 months ago and am very satisfied. the swivel and rocking functions are very smooth.  My only complaint is the the fabric covering the footrest are tore where it connects to the extension on both chairs relatively soon after chairs were received.  Doesn't really bother me as you don't see it when footrest is in the closed position. This type of rip results when there is not enough fabric allowance at the seam when constructing the cover.