I would give these a 4.75 if I could.
They are much deeper than I anticipated, very sturdy and overall nice nightstands.
Warning, they are VERY heavy! 
They took a while to put together, but the instructions are very clear so it’s easy enough.
Two issues the legs could be secured a little better. I’ll probably reinforce them with another screw. Also the top of one of the tables didn’t lock in very well so moving it may be an issue.