Would be 5 star with improved assembly instructions. This sideboard is fantastic. Once assembled, it's well made, feels really solid, and I think it's going to hold up for a very long time. However, the directions for it are horribly written and at least in our case were missing an entire page right in the middle of a particularly confusing set of steps. Thankfully, my husband and I are good enough at building furniture that we figured it out ... but it was an obnoxious process. The box is very heavy, but that's not a bad thing since it's a piece of real furniture. Would absolutely buy another, just go into it knowing you may have a headache getting it built.