These were bought to replace some we had gotten from another web site purchase that was bad.  We are VERY happy with these.  The assembly went great, they are nice and sturdy and I get compliments on them all the time. The only thing that makes me rate these as a 4 is that the color is not exactly what I had expected.  The best description for the Ivory color is that it looks more like an old piano key. Otherwise we like them and they work out great!