Shelves were exactly what we wanted, look even better in person than in the picture.  We were going for an older rustic look and the two shelves we received fit the bill perfectly.  Both pieces are full of character, with a little bit of contour on the edges (but will still fit flat against a wall).  There is a subtle coating/finish on the shelves to prevent slivers, etc. without detracting from the overall look.  As is clearly indicated in other reviews, you do need to supply your own brackets.