Would be 5 stars, but like some others said the lights aren't truly black. They are oil-rubbed bronze, but pretty much look black. They look great in our master bathroom and you honestly can't tell looking at them. All wayfair needs to do is just change the color in the description and they'd be 5 stars! Shipping was quick and undamaged. We loved this style so much we bought the 2-light and 3-light versions for our 3 other bathrooms!