When the canisters arrived they were just as cute as the photo. The two smaller canisters seal great and would be perfect for what I ordered them for (granulated sugar and brown sugar). The lid to the large canister doesn't fit inside the canister at all, even with the silicone sealing ring removed. Luckily wayfair is great with handling returns. Upon further inspection the small canister is matte finished and the other two are glossy. I would not recommend this product!