I gave it 4 stars because the directions could have been better. 
The stools are beautiful and seem to be well made. I purchased it so that my husband could sit comfortably at the counter and work on his laptop.
He said it is really comfy ad we like the ring to pull them so we don't have to touch the fabric.  I hope they hold up as far as comfort is concerned.  Overall very happy with my purchase. Classy and elegant! Looks great with my white kitchen and marble counter tops!