If I were to rate this piece on looks alone, it would be 5 star, no question.  But the frustration in putting it together, over 3 HOURS - definitely knocks it down for me.  The piece itself is a beautiful color, and very heavy.  The craftsmanship could be better.  There were multiple issues- starting trivially with some of the screws being mislabeled, but then we started noticing that several of the screw holes were drilled wider than the screws, and others weren't drilled deep enough. Then we realized that the drawer groove was at a VERY slight upward angle which puts it off just a bit.  Thankfully you won't see that since it's inside.  Overall, I would recommend this- but just be prepared to devote an evening to  putting it together!