While overall I really like the door, my expectation is that the door would have been sanded to be completely smooth versus have rough and rugged wood that if not careful could splinter if hand rubs against it. The stain was done pretty well. The door is solid and heavy, assembly was fairly simple, and install with the holes already bored out for the rollers made install easier as well. Another reason I took a star off is because the manufacture did not include the track for hanging the door, and it took a while to receive it once contacted. Overall, I am satisfied with the door and it looks great hung.