My husband and I are already fighting over this chair! It's very comfy and the recliner buttons/motion is quiet. Really like the color and can't wait to rock our sweet baby in this chair. The reason I gave 4 out of 5 was because the back rest is a little short (for my husband) and the chair is just a little too tall (for me). My husband is 5'9" and his head hangs over quite a bit and with me being 5'5" the backrest isn't the issue, it's the fact that my feet can't touch the ground. I'll just have a pillow behind my back so I can reach the ground and have enough support on my back at the same time.