I really like the chair, it is comfortable and easy to relax in. Trouble is , that is it so slightly tippy. It will not tip over, i tried, but it gives that feel when you get out of it. Also I am 6'3'' and the way the recliner sits, my legs from mid calf down hang off the chair. Has taken some time to get used to it. I love the small footprint, and the fact it can be closer to the wall. The pull tab to recline is awesome, but you recline fully back, and there you slowly more often than not begin to slowly drift back to the base recline position.  So 4 stars is fair, and maybe even a bit generous. What I love about the chair, I really LOVE, and the other things are things i can get used too.