I give it 5 stars. however I wish I had considered durability and comfortability.  I may have purchased something different had I considered those factors.  The material seems like it may easily tear.  I have a cat and she jumped on it as soon as it came out the box making small puncture wounds that are noticable.  My last set could handle her jumps. I had to purchase rubber mittens to keep her off.  Also, though they look very nice in my living room, they are not comfortable enough to lounge in.  These put me more in the mind of seating in an office setting. Not much give in the seat cushion as the set is very firm.