I would give it a 4 star or maybe 5. Here is the issue, the light switch on/off also has a fan speed setting. It is not the sturdiest and you have to manually click it up to the setting you want. It is not a smooth transition between speeds and the little button knob does not seem sturdy, it is a bad design. Rather than gliding, it has to be pushed into the next fan speed. Would rather have had a remote or pull chains from the fan.