PROS:
-the quality and sturdiness of the stools are amazing
- swivel and adjustable height makes it easy to get in and out of our island
-not flimsy! 
-great price
- already got lots of compliments on it

CONS:
-when i sit on it, the seat goes down a bit, but bounces back into position.  I'm 120 lbs.  It's not a big deal, but i'm waiting to see how it fares with a heavy person on it. 

I bought 6 of these for my long island, and of the 6, there was one manufacturer defect where the metal around the seat was warped.  Wayfair was prompt and replaced it right away.  This gave me confidence to order from Wayfair again because the customer service is pretty amazing.  Thanks Wayfair.