I really like the crème shag rug.  I purchased it for our lake house and I've only actually seen it a couple of times, but it seems to be just perfect.  I can't really comment of if it sheds with use or anything like that as we haven't really "used" it that much yet.  Looks wise I can tell you that it's picture perfect and exactly like what I saw on your site.  There's nothing disappointing about it so far.  We'll see how it fares over time, but so far it's wonderful!