I’d say the rug is a 4 star. Looks pretty nice, quality is good. It’s subtle in colouring but the browns are darker and the blue is more vibrant than the pictures show so depends on the look you want. The extra star is for the service provided by Wayfair when the less than perfect rug arrived. The delivery company dragged it along the pavement like it was a piece of sidewalk chalk in an intense game of tic tax toe.  I’m sure fragments of the rug lay like breadcrumbs to my doorstep. Thank you for being awesome Wayfair, making it right and understanding the disappointment.