I ordered three sets in red to replace my old, dark, heavy stoneware. The Godinger Gathering exceeded my expectations! These plates are sturdy, but don't weigh a ton individually, and stand up well enough that I'm not concerned when my kids clear their own plates from the table. The bowls are perfect for cereal and stack well in the cupboard. Salad plates are smaller than what I am used to, but they serve their purpose well. However, they are not perfect whatsoever. Several plates have a slight warp compared to others and the red rims are not evenly shaded. This does not bother me personally, as I like the "aged" appearance. Two of the mugs were broken in shipping, but Wayfair replaced them quickly with another set. All in all, my order was here quickly, and the replacements dishes as well, resulting in a very happy customer who will love using these plates for years to come!