I bought this grate to replace the griddle that came with my new stove.  The quality of the grate is excellent and the color and texture of the grate is an excellent match to the grates that are already on the stove.  I would have given this grate an overall rating of 5 if the tines/spokes of this grate weren't of a different style from the grates that came with the stove.  The stove is brand new and I used the GE website to find all of the accessories related to the stove; this grate was the only accessory listed so I thought it would be an exact match.  The new grate has tapered tines/spokes and the grates that came with the stove have squared off tines/spokes.  I would have given this grate a 5 rating if the tines/spokes were an exact match to the ones already on the stove.  If such a thing exists, I would like to be pointed to it!