For me it's 4 stars. I really like it! It does the job as far as I have something new in my living room to sit and lounge in but I don't think this is a formal living room piece. I think this is more for a basement or gameroom than a living. If I was buying it for my basement I probably would have raised it to 5 stars! The delivery team for me though was outstanding, the assembly of this was very easy and simple and it is extremely comfortable to sit and lounge in.