I was really excited to get this water hose storage caddy. It's well made and looks good. It's a perfect size for large hoses. I would've given it five stars but didn't for one reason only. There is a hole for the hose to feed into and the cut-out hole is rough; it should be smooth or have a gasket liner. I'm worried that the rough edge may cut through my softer/flexible hoses with regular friction. If that was improved, I'd  definitely give it a five-star rating.