Sturdy, well made and attractive. Sink is sufficiently protected from our clunky dish tossing ways. I was happy to find black because gray didn't look good in my kitchen.
No stars lost but It's not the exact size I need and I think if you cut in the right areas it would look ok, better than some that don't have the vertical lines, but still it's not ideal to lose bottom feet/nubs, and I would suggest it's much better to find the right size if you at all can.
It came in a small box packed in a giant box that would fit 10+ of these mats. So actually 1/2 star lost. 4.5.