I only gave this a 3 because we have ordered other fur blankets that were a solid 5 and actually resulted in multiple buys.  If I was basing it on warmth alone- a definite 5.  For softness of the fur, only a 2-3.  When the blanket came it was stiff - not what I had expected.  I will admit I have not washed it yet.  The color was a deep rich brown.  It almost reminds me of the feel / texture of a bear rug.  Not that I have one - but you know those outdoor stores and at zoos sometimes they have samples of the fur to feel.  That is what it reminded me of.  The underside is soft, just the fur side not as luxurious soft.  

Pros: Extremely warm
Cons: A little stiff