I gave it a 4 because it looks different than the photo. To me colors in the photo are muted. Pics on the duvet cover are clear and bright. I kept it because I love the feel of the fabric. It’s cotton and so comfortable. I don’t usually like shams because they are so hard to get on a pillow resulting in a hard scrunched up pillow. These though are roomy with a hidden zipper. Love the comfort and quality of this set.