This is perfect for the shoe bench I just bought. It can hold 4 pairs of my 10 and 8 year olds shoes. I like how the liner soften it a bit. I think this will last longer that the other  bins and won't go out of shape easily.  Our 9 month old twins pretended this is a toy car. They rode it while the bigger sibs pushes the bin on the floor. That's the test how I knew this will last longer than the others.