This feather topper is great! Extremely nice quality, fluffs up great and after 4 nights sleeping on it, no feathers have poked thru. For those that say it flattens when you lay on it, obviously, they are feathers. My guess is these reviewers have never used any sort of feather bed in the past. I highly recommend this. Only consideration is that because of its thickness, when you make your bed, the bedspread isn’t very smooth. The fluff of the feathers can show as “lumpy”. So if you’re obsessed with a picture perfect smooth bed then this is not for you. Otherwise it’s extremely luxurious and snuggly. We have a sleep number bed that I hate and this has made it much more bearable.