We got the graphite chair.  I like the look of it, and I find it very comfortable to sit in.  My only quibbles would be that I didn't realize the legs were plastic, and the seat makes a mildly annoying sound when you first sit in it.  We've only had it for a week or so, though, and I am hopeful that the latter will cease when it "settles" in a bit more.  Otherwise, great chair for the price.