This is a beautiful piece of furniture and overall great quality.  I gave the rating a 4 because it took my husband a long time to put together (hes very good at assembling furniture).  The predrilled holes for the drawer slides were off so this resulted in wobbly drawers and my husband had to sand down the corners of the inserts to the bottom of the drawers so when all the sides of the drawers were put together they fit flush.  The cushion on top is a snug fit which prevents it from sliding off.  Overall a good quality piece and I would recommend it.