These are really nice bar stools and they are sturdy and seem to be well made. I ordered the counter height for my center island and they work very well. I wanted a backless counter stool that I could tuck under the counter and these fit perfectly. The finish is very nice and the seats are generous in size and comfortable.I got them in black. I haven't experienced any shedding of the rush seats and these are not scratchy or rough at all. All around a good purchase- especially for the money. You can't beat the price.