We looked at a lot of bar stools before deciding on this one.  My husband and I built our retirement home without a separate dining room.  We don't do a lot of entertaining but do have family gatherings.  Our kitchen is an eat-in kitchen with a table and chairs that stores an extra leaf to extend to accomodate 8 chairs.  Perfect.  The island is adjacent and has a bar edge that extends.  We really wanted stools with backs but felt it would make the eating area too crowded  This stool tucks most of the way under the ledge when not in use.  The stool is very sturdy and well made.  We purchased 3.  The only reason I give it 4 stars is I would have preferred a little higher rise in the back.  Otherwise would definitely give it a 5-star.