Difficult to rate. It’s beautiful and just what I was looking for. I like it so much that I’ve decided to keep it despite some quality control problems. The first tray I received had a finish problem on top rim and along the base with narrow white streaks where the finish should have been. Couldn’t keep it because location was too visible. Replacement was fine in the those areas, but has a patch of  finish of about 3 inches along side of rim that is duller than the rest. I can turn the tray in a way that company unlikely to notice., so I am keeping it.  Wayfair  was very accommodating about the return and replacement.